Friday 20 November 2026 | Julian Milford KC, Raphael Hogarth, Christopher Knight KC

Share

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal (Lady Carmichael P, Chamberlain J and Johnson J) has handed down judgment in Apple Inc v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] UKIPTrib 9. The judgment is available here.

The Tribunal decided that it may be confirmed, in public, that the Secretary of State has given Apple a technical capability notice under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016. The judgment confirms that Apple has challenged this notice before the Tribunal.

The Secretary of State contended that the parties should be required to ‘neither confirm nor deny’ in open proceedings whether Apple has been given a notice. Apple disagreed, and contended that the open justice principle required that this central feature of the case was not kept secret.

The Tribunal held that the Secretary of State had failed to show that confirming the existence of a technical capability notice would damage national security. The Government had already departed from its policy of ‘neither confirm nor deny’ by, the Tribunal inferred, authorising official briefings to the press, and authorising Apple to brief US Administration officials. The Tribunal held that anyone with even a passing interest in this topic already knew that the Secretary of State had served a technical capability notice on Apple.

Julian Milford KC and Raphael Hogarth appeared for Apple, with Daniel Beard KC of Monckton Chambers and Gayatri Sarathy of Blackstone Chambers, instructed by Fieldfisher.

Christopher Knight KC appeared for the Secretary of State for the Home Department, with Neil Sheldon KC of 1 Crown Office Row, Karl Laird of Landmark Chambers and Hugo Murphy of Blackstone Chambers, instructed by the Government Legal Department

Related Insights

  1. View News
  2. View News
  3. View News
  4. View News
  5. View News
  6. View News
  7. View News
  8. View News

View more →