Friday 20 November 2026 | Jonathan Moffett KC

Share

The High Court has today handed down judgment in R (Rushcliffe Specialist Schools (Mickleover) Ltd) v Derby City Council [2026] EWHC 2940 (Admin).

The case concerns the duty on a local authority under section 63(2) of the Children and Families Act 2014 to pay “any fees payable” in respect of education or training provided at a special school to a child with an EHC plan.

An independent special school had sought to increase its fees, but the Council had declined to pay the increased fees. The school argued that, because there was no contract between it and the Council which specified the fees to be paid, s 63(2) required the Council to pay whatever fees the school demanded.

Kolinsky J rejected the school’s proposed interpretation of s 63(2). In particular, he held that:

  • The word “payable” in s 63(2) bears its ordinary meaning of “required to be paid”, consistent with its use throughout the education legislation. Section 63(2) assumes a basis for payment elsewhere and does not confer on a school a unilateral power to set its fees.
  • The purpose of s 63(2) is to protect parents from bearing the cost of provision, not to give independent schools a public law route to recovery.
  • The school’s interpretation would create a stark asymmetry of pricing power over a service of real public importance, and could undermine the stability of placements.

Given the pressure on high needs budgets, the judgment gives local authorities and providers important clarity: disputes over fees at independent special schools fall to be resolved through the underlying private law relationship, not through a public law duty under the 2014 Act.

Jonathan Moffett KC (instructed by Browne Jacobson) acted for the successful Defendant, Derby City Council.

Related Insights

  1. View News
  2. View News
  3. View News
  4. View Insights
  5. View Insights
  6. View News
  7. View Insights
  8. View News

View more →